Are all cold contacts scams? 3 easy ways for authors to vet the people in their inbox


Cold calls, cold emails, DMs, comments about "how inspiring" your unreleased book is, Author's are bombarded daily with scam attempts, so how do authors determine if any of the cold contacts are genuine? And how should a creative approach an author they want to work with?
Most people will say that you should turn to websites like Fiverr or Reedsy. To that, I would say that those sites aren't vetted so you should vet your creatives on there as well. I've seen numerous Fiverr book covers and book trailers that use unapproved AI generated content and stolen clips and images from Copywritten works, and the platform doesn't seem to be putting a stop to it. Earlier in my career I attempted to find clients through Fiverr and found that my pricing structure while realistic was not for the clientele of Fiverr and that I would always be overlooked for someone cheaper or with higher ratings because they had been on the site longer. As for Reedsy, I've resubmitted applicaitons with each new book cover I've been hired to do and each time I've been denied requesting more work samples, so I don't know who the other creatives are on the site or how they passed the application process. These are delicate areas that spark a lot of debate online. As both a creative looking to work with authors and a marketer that manages Social Media and Email accounts for authors and has sent out hundreds of cold emails in hopes of growing my network. I've compiled three easy ways to vet the cold contacts and approach partnerships that can benefit everyone in the industry.
So here's the scenario: You've received an email from someone claiming to be a marketer or creative that wants to work with you. The email seems real and isn't the same copy and paste template you've received a dozen times already today. But they didn't attach any links. And that is the first red flag. However, we know that people can make mistakes and you just so happen to need the services this person is offering. So you follow these steps to determine if they are a scammer or just a marketer struggling through the economy like everyone else.
do your due dillegence
Google the name and email address that sent you the email. You may or may not quickly find that the email and person associated with it are real and are actual creatives. Now, double check the email address and make sure there isn't a typo hidden in the address. If they've passed these steps, they are ahead of the game. If you can't find them on Google, they may already not be the person you want because your goal is visibilty. You can always ask them for links to their portfolio and websites but remember DO NOT CLICK THE LINK! That's how they steal information. Always type out whatever the link said diretly into your URL bar. If it ends in .app and looks like a templated AI site, it is. These are becomming extremely popular for scams. If the website passes your initial tests you can always check the traffic on the site through different free resources, these will tell you where the site is hosted from, how long it's been up, and even how much traffic the site receives monthly.
CHECK THE REFERENCES
If you've found their website or social media, then they should display some of their past work. If they claim to be the artist of the newest Stephen King or Freida McFadden novel, chances are they are lying. You can easily Google cover artists and if they're properly credited, the answer should be available. If the portfolio seems real and not artist credit is given, contact the author of the book covers that they claim to be the artists of. This may take a few days to hear back on. Or if they don't have a publicly listed contact, you may have to ask the Cold Emailer for references you can contact. If all the reference emails are formatted with FirstNameLastNameNumber at the same email domain as the original contact (gmail, yahoo, etc.) then chances are they are their own references. A phone call with the references can clear up a lot of confusion if you consider yourself fairly observant.
FEEL OUT THE CONTACT
You hold all the power, they contacted you. So don't be afraid to make your needs and demands known. You more than likely need a communicative partner so set up an initial phone or video call to see if your communication styles work well together. Request their pricing structure before presenting your budget. If their offerings seem too good to be true, it probably is. If they demand your budget before presenting a price estimate or package options then they are just there to drain your bank account. And always be up front and check your contracts to restrict Generative AI use so that your book isn't slapped with "AI-Generated Content" tags when you spent so much time writing the book just to have a lazy designer ruin your reach. I know that no matter what I say in a cold email or how I approach an author, there's a high percentage chance they write me off as a scam. I'm in the Author groups on Facebook and I see the compalints. So I guess my question for authors is, how do you go about finding your marketing team or creatives? And how would you like to be approached by people who want to work with you? When I worked with another firm most of the clientele came from ads in magazines, but most independent creatives can't afford ad space and no one can control the algorithm. Let's get the conversation started in the comments below.


Comments